Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep: Gentle & Effective Tips

When your baby slowly drifts off to sleep at your breast, it’s truly a magical moment. Skin-to-skin contact and sleep-inducing hormones help your little one relax deeply (and probably you as well).

Since breastfeeding is such a valuable experience and strengthens the bond between mom and baby tremendously, it’s no wonder that nursing to sleep is so popular.

However, once the newborn phase is long past or sleep problems become overwhelming, many moms start looking for alternative soothing methods. They wonder: How can I wean my baby off nursing to sleep? And how can I do this gently and gradually?

To answer these questions, I’ve written this article. Here, I’ll share proven methods to help you transition away from nursing to sleep.

By the way, have you heard about our free baby sleep course?

Drawbacks of Nursing to Sleep

Despite all the beautiful, cozy benefits—especially in the early months—nursing to sleep also has some downsides. Here are the three most common ones:

1. Developing a Nursing-to-Sleep Association

Of course, it’s wonderful to use the bonding and sleep-inducing effects of breastfeeding.

However, over time, many parents realize that their baby only accepts nursing as a way to soothe and fall asleep. Without sucking at the breast, sleep seems impossible.

This may be perfectly fine as long as it works. But this “dependency” can become a challenge when…

• it’s time to wean,
• mom wants to spend an evening away from home, or
• the baby keeps waking up and needs to nurse in order to fall back asleep.

Since babies become strongly attached to their bedtime routine, their bodies learn from an early age that they can only relax and fall asleep through nursing.

Breaking the habit of nursing to sleep (known as the „nursing-to-sleep association“) is one of the hardest steps—especially if a baby is not used to any alternatives (such as a stroller, baby carrier, or pacifier).

2. Emotional Strain on Mom

As wonderful as breastfeeding is, it can be exhausting when your baby wakes up for the fourth time at 3 AM and will only settle back to sleep at your breast.

In a time when postpartum depression is, unfortunately, on the rise, it’s crucial to minimize sleep deprivation and stress in every possible way.

If dad or another caregiver can help with putting the baby to sleep (using a pacifier, babywearing, or rocking) or feeding (e.g., pumped breast milk in a bottle), moms have more energy and time to adjust to their new life, hormonal shifts, and lack of sleep.

3. No Alternative Caregivers Available

Sharing both the joys and the challenges of feeding can be beneficial not just for mom. If you’d like your partner to experience these special moments or if you’re planning to return to work early, introducing a bottle alongside breastfeeding can be helpful (even with pumped breast milk).

Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep at 6 Months

Weaning off nursing to sleep becomes increasingly difficult after six months. That means it’s best to introduce alternative sleep methods early on and use them at least once a day.

This way, your baby learns to fall asleep without having a breast in their mouth—whether in a baby carrier with dad, in a stroller with grandma, or with a pacifier in bed. This not only gives you some relief but also brings back some flexibility to your daily life (for example, if you have a doctor’s appointment and dad needs to put the baby to bed). It can also be emotionally beneficial and beautifully strengthen the father-child bond.

When Should You Stop Nursing to Sleep?

In the early weeks, it’s perfectly fine to let your baby fall asleep at the breast. But after the newborn phase, it’s worth observing whether nursing to sleep is becoming a problem.

This varies greatly from family to family and even from one sibling to another.

Breast as a Pacifier Substitute

Even when breastfeeding is fulfilling, many moms eventually feel like their breast has become a pacifier substitute—often accompanied by a sense of exhaustion or frustration.

Many studies highlight the soothing benefits of breastfeeding for infant pain relief.

So yes, in a way, we moms really are a “human pacifier” for our little ones. And during teething or illnesses, that’s perfectly fine.

However, if your baby constantly demands to nurse—day and night—without actually drinking much, but rather sucking and „snacking,“ it may be time to start weaning off nursing to sleep.

Nursing to Sleep and Naptime Challenges

Humans are creatures of habit. We all have specific rituals and conditions for sleep—maybe you can only sleep in total darkness, with a special pillow, or with the window open?

Just like us, babies develop sleep habits early on. The key question is whether these habits support long-term sleep quality or hinder it.

If nursing is the only way your baby can fall asleep, it may negatively affect nap duration—especially between 4 and 8 months. Many babies struggle to extend their naps beyond 45 minutes. The only way to lengthen them often involves mom staying nearby for every nap, ready to intervene as soon as the baby stirs. And by „intervene,“ you guessed it—nursing again.

Frequent Nighttime Nursing

One of the main reasons parents want to wean off nursing to sleep is the disrupted sleep it causes at night.

Many babies who are “dependent” on nursing to drift off struggle to stay asleep without it.

A baby’s sleep cycles last only about 45 minutes—much shorter than those of adults—so the likelihood of frequent night wakings is high.

This often leads to fragmented sleep and severe sleep deprivation for mom. Instead of naturally transitioning between sleep cycles, your baby wakes up thinking, „Wait, I’m supposed to sleep without the breast now? Where did mom’s breast go?“ And so, they call for it—again and again and again. You get the idea.

Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep – 5 Helpful Tips

If your baby has made nursing to sleep their favorite habit, don’t worry—it can be changed.

Let’s now talk about how you can gradually teach your baby to fall asleep without nursing.

Here are my top 5 tips:

1. Create Ideal Sleep Conditions

Setting up good sleep conditions is one of the most important steps in gently and fairly introducing your child to new sleep habits.

This includes establishing a somewhat consistent daily rhythm, so your baby’s body learns when to feel tired (and when not to).

A consistent and early bedtime is also incredibly helpful.

As the evening approaches, it’s best to introduce a calming period. This will help your baby relax and prepare for sleep. For example, limit active play, avoid screens, and reduce stimulation 1–2 hours before bedtime. If visitors come over, it’s best if they leave before this period, and rough play should stop. Dimming the lights can also help signal that bedtime is near.

Playing soothing music (or white noise for younger babies) can also be an effective cue that sleep time is approaching.

Additionally, ensuring your baby gets enough daytime sleep is key. An overtired or overstimulated baby will struggle to settle, both for naps and at bedtime. Unfortunately, poor daytime sleep and poor nighttime sleep often go hand in hand.

Bedtime Routines Work Wonders

A consistent bedtime routine with a predictable sequence of activities (such as brushing teeth, putting on a sleep sack, and singing a lullaby in a dim room) can be extremely helpful for babies. Research shows that a structured routine promotes better sleep by providing a sense of order and security. When your baby knows what’s coming next, their body starts releasing sleep hormones in preparation for rest.

By the way, my free baby sleep course provides valuable guidance on how to implement these strategies.

Tired? Exhausted? Feeling lost?

SIGN UP NOW FOR THE FREE BABY SLEEP COURSE.

Feedback from Emily:

You hear and read a lot about sleep training programs and tips for falling and staying asleep. But in this course, you receive a daily email with step-by-step guidance in the right direction. At the same time, everything can be individually adapted to your baby and your family situation. It has helped us so much—our baby now sleeps several hours longer at a stretch. Naps during the day take no more than 5 minutes to settle, and bedtime in the evening takes at most 30 minutes. Thank you so much for this course!

Yes! I want to try this.

2. Separate Nursing from Falling Asleep

If your baby has a bedtime routine, one of the most crucial steps is to separate nursing from falling asleep. This can be done gradually (using the weaning method described below) or suddenly by moving nursing to the beginning of the bedtime routine, about 10–15 minutes before your baby usually falls asleep.

For younger babies, the eat-play-sleep cycle can be helpful. This means your baby consistently gets used to being fed after a nap rather than being nursed to sleep. This way, the association between nursing and sleeping is completely avoided.

3. Secret Tip: Calming Your Baby with the „5 S’s“

When a baby cries, it can be difficult for new moms to bear. Nursing is such a simple and effective way to calm a baby instantly, no matter the reason behind the fussiness.

However, sucking isn’t the only way to soothe a crying baby.

Renowned baby sleep expert Harvey Karp introduced the “5 S’s” method. These five techniques, when used together, have an incredibly calming effect on babies:

• sucking (e.g., on a pinky finger or pacifier),
• swaddling,
• side or stomach position (placing the baby on their side or stomach while awake),
• shushing (making a “shhh” sound),
• swinging (gentle rocking motion).

When used together, these techniques work like magic and have even been proven to soothe babies after vaccinations. So, it’s definitely worth giving them a try.

4. Finding Alternatives to Nursing to Sleep

Once nursing is separated from falling asleep, the next step is to find alternative soothing methods.

For example, dad could take over once the baby has finished nursing and is already drowsy. At this point, mom should step back completely and trust that dad will find his own way to comfort their little one, even if there is some initial protest. Yes, there will likely be a few nights of strong resistance, but this usually fades quickly once your baby realizes they can fall asleep in other ways.

Instead of nursing, mom or dad can use stroking, cuddling, rocking, babywearing, a pacifier, or similar soothing techniques. Playing calming background music can also be helpful, even if your baby doesn’t seem interested at first.

5. Best Time of Day to Start the Weaning Process

One important question remains: What is the best time of day or night to start weaning off nursing to sleep?

There are different approaches, each with pros and cons.

In my consultations, I usually recommend practicing at bedtime first before addressing night wakings. The reason? Sleep pressure is highest in the evening, making it easier to see progress.

The same applies to the first nap of the day, which is often the easiest to manage. Once improvements are seen here, you can gradually work on other naps and night wakings.

Of course, the best approach depends on your child’s age and individual situation.

In some cases, tackling everything at once can be effective. However, it’s generally best not to overwhelm your baby with too many changes at the same time. You could start with all daytime and evening sleep times simultaneously or focus solely on bedtime and address night wakings later.

Gently Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep (The Gradual Withdrawal Method)

If you want to phase out nursing to sleep as gently as possible, the gradual withdrawal method (popularized by Elizabeth Pantley) is an excellent choice. It can be used with babies as young as 3–4 months and is designed to wean them off nursing to sleep slowly and gently.

Here’s how to implement it:

1. Detaching from the Breast Earlier Than Usual

If your baby currently nurses until they are in a deep sleep (meaning they rely on 100% nursing to fall asleep), start by detaching them at 90% instead.

To do this, gently insert your pinky finger into the corner of their mouth to break the suction.

It can also help to carefully shift your baby slightly upward, encouraging them to fall asleep without sucking.

2. Introducing Alternative Sleep Cues

Now, help your baby fall asleep using other methods: gentle patting, whispering „shhh“, rocking, singing, etc.

If they cry and won’t settle, nurse again. As they start to doze off, try once more to unlatch them slightly earlier than before.

Repeat this process as many times as needed until your baby falls asleep without sucking. (This may take several attempts!)

3. Gradually Reducing Nursing Time

Once this works somewhat, begin unlatching at 80%, then 70%, and so on, until your baby can fully fall asleep without nursing.

If you’re lucky, this will naturally improve night wakings as well.

Since this method is very gentle, you can use it for all sleep situations, including nighttime wakings.

4. Practice Makes Perfect

Don’t get discouraged if progress is slow at first or if success isn’t linear. This method requires patience and persistence.

But the reward is worth it—seeing your child fall asleep happily and peacefully without nursing and waking up less frequently during the night.

The Cry in Loving Arms (CLA) Method

Cry in Loving Arms (CLA) is a more direct approach than the gradual withdrawal method.

CLA is a structured sleep coaching method that I developed based on developmental psychology. It is often used in a similar way in „Emotional First Aid“—especially for babies who cry excessively or have high needs.

I have had excellent experiences with this method, particularly for babies aged 4–8 months, and when the gradual withdrawal method doesn’t work or feels too slow. You can find more details about the CLA method here.

Are you looking for even more insights and practical guidance on helping your child transition away from nursing to sleep—whether gently or more quickly? Then sign up for my free baby sleep course.

Conclusion – Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep

Breastfeeding is a beautiful and highly beneficial experience—for bonding, for your baby’s health, and for their immune system!

However, if you feel that the downsides of nursing to sleep are becoming overwhelming or if you want to establish healthy sleep habits from the start, you can absolutely create change within a few weeks—or even just days.

It will likely require patience and consistency to show your little one that other sleep routines can be just as comforting.

But once your baby learns to fall asleep peacefully without your help, your nights will often improve naturally. The result—hopefully more sleep for everyone—is well worth the effort.

FAQ – Common Questions About Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep

Will my baby stop nursing to sleep on their own?

Yes, nursing to sleep usually fades naturally over time. As children grow, they develop their own sleep habits and become less dependent on their parents for falling asleep. This typically happens between the ages of one and three, depending on the child’s personality and circumstances.

Gradually introducing a bedtime routine and new sleep rituals can help ease this transition.

How long should I nurse my baby to sleep?

There is no fixed rule for how long you should nurse your baby to sleep. Ultimately, it depends on what works best for you and your child.

The World Health Organization recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months and continued breastfeeding for up to two years or beyond, depending on your and your baby’s needs.

From experience, it can be helpful to introduce alternatives to nursing to sleep as early as 2–3 months old. This is often easier at a younger age before babies become strongly attached to nursing as their only way of falling asleep.

Pay attention to both your baby’s needs and your own. If nursing to sleep leads to frequent night wakings and sleep deprivation, you can absolutely consider making a change.

How long does it take to wean a baby off nursing to sleep?

For many babies and toddlers, nursing to sleep is a deeply ingrained habit that can contribute to ongoing sleep difficulties. If you decide to wean your baby off this habit, you can expect the transition to take about one to two weeks. However, since every child is different, it may take a shorter or longer time depending on their development and temperament.

Your baby will likely protest at first, but they will also learn within a few days that other soothing methods can be just as comforting—especially if you remain confident in your decision. Sleep routines are flexible, and with consistency, your child will adjust to new ones.

If you’re lucky, your baby may quickly accept alternative sleep cues—such as being rocked by dad, using a pacifier, or being gently swayed to sleep. In that case, the transition could be complete within just a few days.

How Can You Wean Your Baby Off Nursing to Sleep?

To help your baby transition away from nursing to sleep, try these steps:

1. Establish a consistent bedtime routine that helps your baby relax, such as reading a book, cuddling, listening to soft music, or singing a lullaby.
2. Ensure your baby is well-fed before bedtime.
3. Nurse your baby only until they are drowsy, then try alternative ways to help them fall asleep, such as rocking or gentle stroking.
4. Offer alternative comfort items like a pacifier or a cuddly toy. Many babies need time to get used to these before they accept them as soothing alternatives.
5. Gradually shorten the nursing time before bed to help your baby get used to falling asleep with less nursing. (But only reduce the feeding time directly before sleep.)
6. Alternatively, separate nursing from sleep either gradually or suddenly by placing it at the beginning of the bedtime routine, about 10–15 minutes before the usual sleep time.

What Are the Alternatives to Nursing to Sleep?

There are several alternatives to nursing to sleep that can help your baby settle:

1. Calming bedtime routine: Introduce relaxing rituals before sleep that always follow the same sequence. Keep it simple, such as: diaper change, putting on a sleep sack, looking at a book, playing soft music, rocking, or singing a lullaby.
2. Physical closeness: Provide comfort through cuddling, gentle stroking, and holding your baby close without nursing.
3. Pacifier: Some babies find sucking on a pacifier soothing and relaxing.
4. Comfort objects: Soft toys or security blankets can provide a sense of security and help with sleep. Babies often need time to form an attachment to these items, so consistent use is key.
5. White noise or calming sounds: Some babies sleep better with background noise, such as white noise, rain, or ocean waves—especially in the first 4–6 months. Later on, soft music or relaxation sounds may be beneficial.
6. Proven calming strategies: Think about what already soothes your baby and try using it as a sleep aid instead of nursing, such as rocking, gentle bouncing, or dad singing a lullaby. Even if these methods may later need to be phased out, they can create a gradual transition away from nursing to sleep.

Every baby is different, so experimenting with different methods can help you find what works best. Whatever you try, give it at least 4–5 days/nights before deciding whether it’s effective—babies need time to adjust to new routines.

How Can I Teach My Baby to Sleep Without Nursing?

To help your baby learn to sleep without nursing, follow these steps:

1. Establish a consistent bedtime routine: Set up a predictable sequence of relaxing activities before sleep, such as looking at a book, singing a lullaby, or giving a gentle baby massage.
2. Feed your baby before starting the bedtime routine: This way, your baby is full before the sleep routine begins, helping them break the association between nursing and sleep. Often, this transition works best gradually—nursing until they are drowsy and then using an alternative method to help them sleep.
3. Cuddle or gently stroke your baby: Provide physical comfort and reassurance without nursing.
4. Introduce a pacifier or a comfort object: These can offer soothing comfort instead of nursing.
5. Be patient and consistent: Stick with the process, as it may take time for your baby to adjust to new sleep habits.

It’s important to be responsive to your baby’s needs and try different approaches until you find what works best for both of you.

Weaning Off Nursing to Sleep at 2 Years Old

To help your 2-year-old transition away from nursing to sleep, try these steps:

1. Talk to your child: Explain how bedtime will work from now on. Your toddler understands more than you might think. Use simple words and stick to what you say. It can also help to create a visual bedtime chart with simple pictures or symbols and practice it during the day.
2. Use positive reinforcement: Praise your child in the morning for falling asleep without nursing—regardless of how much they protested. Let them know how proud you are and emphasize that they are now a “big girl” or “big boy.” For older toddlers, a small reward, like a special sticker, can also be motivating.
3. Establish a comforting, consistent bedtime routine: Follow a relaxing sequence of activities every night in the exact same order (including brushing teeth and putting on pajamas or a sleep sack).
4. Feed your child before the bedtime routine begins: This ensures they are full before starting the wind-down process.
5. Offer cuddles and gentle touch: Provide warmth and reassurance through cuddling and stroking instead of nursing.
6. Introduce a comfort object: A special stuffed animal or blanket can provide comfort and security. Involve this cuddly friend in daytime play and intentionally encourage attachment. A familiar sleep companion can help ease the transition as your child learns to fall asleep more independently.
7. Be patient and consistent: Patience and loving consistency are key. It may take some time for your child to fully adjust to the new sleep routine.

Pay attention to your child’s needs and trust your instincts about which strategies to use and how quickly to proceed. Once you start the transition, it’s best to follow through completely. A 2-year-old may become confused and even more resistant to change if the process is inconsistent.